Best of the Week
of Sept. 29, 2002
Best of Week Archives
Here are the most intriguing cross-cultural exchanges either begun
or advanced during the week of Sept. 29, 2002, as selected by Y? These postings,
as well as "Best of the Week" entries from previous weeks, also can be found
by accessing Y?'s database using the search form
, or, in the case of answers posted before April 24, 1999, in the
(all questions from the Original Archives have been entered into
the database as well). In the Original Archives, as well as in the database,
you will find questions that have received answers, as well as questions
still awaiting responses. You are encouraged to answer any questions relevant
to your demographic background, as well as to ask any provocative question
you desire. Answers posted are not necessarily meant to represent the views
of an entire demographic group, but can provide a window into the insights
of an individual from that group.
First-time users should first make a quick stop at Y?'s
guidelines pages for asking
The book on
Y? is here!
"Why Do White People Smell Like Wet Dogs
When They Come Out Of The Rain?"
Associated Press story on "Wet Dogs"
I have found over the years that when I go to the cinema on a date
or with female friends, I often have to explain the plot of movies. Do women
find it more difficult to follow movie storylines? Have other men had this
problem, or am I just picking dumb gals?
David, London, NA, United Kingdom, 32, Male, Christian, African Caribbean,
Straight, Electrician, Technical School, Mesg ID 103200253026
BACK TO TOP
There has been some controversy over the movie 'Barber Shop' starring
Ice Cube and Cedric the Entertainer. The controversy stems from some comments
made by Cedric's character about those we commonly think of as African-American
role models, such as Rosa Parks, Martin Luther King Jr. and Jesse Jackson.
To other African Americans who have seen this movie: Do you believe these
people should be off limits for this type of ridicule, or are some of us
being too sensitive, and is all the commotion 'much ado about nothing'?
J.R., Franklin, VA, United States, 32, Male, Black/African American,
Straight, Systems Analyst, 4 Years of College, Middle class, Mesg ID 926200222910
I think more than the subjects being off limits, it shows us that in the
barber shop (black or white) any subject, no matter how sacred, can be talked
about. I go to my barber every week, not just for the haircut, but to hear
what is being talked about. I think that scene in the movie was saying more
than anything that no subject is off limits here, you can talk about whatever
and have your say on anything if you want. But in my barber shop, you better
be able to back it up or they will talk you out of there!
Aaron, Palo Alto, CA, United States, 31, Male, Christian, Black/African
American, Straight, Customer Service Rep, 2 Years of College, Middle class,
Mesg ID 930200210536
I'm not sure. On one hand I think that we should be grateful for what
they have done, but also I think we should have some sense of humor. I am
leaning more toward the first, though.
D. Finney, St. Louis, MO, United States, 27, Female, Black/African American,
2 Years of College, Middle class, Mesg ID 101200250547
I think people are being just a little too sensitive. What was being shown
in that scene was the kind of discussion that goes on in a barber shop. I
have heard a few people (African Americans) say that about Rosa Parks before,
but not about Martin. But if you remember, in the movie everyone else in
the shop was condemning him for saying those things. Another reason I think
there has been too much negative attention is that this is one of the most
succesful black films in a while. I think on issues about black people, we
like to point to one negative aspect and miss the greatness of the larger
picture. It opened at No. 1. Not a lot of mainstream movies can say that.
K.C.L., Berea, KY, United States, 20, Female, Black/African American,
Student, Mesg ID 102200255703
BACK TO TOP
In Europe, breast implants are still largely weird, a thing porn actresses
do for the money. There are various gory stories circulating about side-effects
(ranging from vague discomfort to sudden death), as well as jokes about the
'stupid bimbos' in fashion and media doing such things to themselves. And
I have heard males complain about the yucky feeling of 'hard-as-tennis balls'
breasts. At the same time, everyone here knows that breast implants have become
very common in the United States. What are male and female views on that
from Americans? Do you consider silicone ordinary by now (like dentures in
old people) or is it still something odd?
T., Munich, NA, Germany, 33, Female, Atheist, Straight, Over 4 Years
of College, Mesg ID 9282002123350
I wouldn't even classify breast
implants as weird; I think they're unsafe and, for the most part, unattractive.
I'm a nudist, so I've seen many women with them, and usually they're easy
to spot: High, firm breasts that never move or sag. I've seen some that look
terrible, like huge basketballs, and some that don't look bad at all. But
I think that primarily, it's an unsafe practice, putting a foreign object
in a woman's body for aesthetic reasons. I don't know if they are hard as
tennis balls because I've never felt any.
Annie, Lawrenceville, GA, United
States, 51, Female, Christian, White/Caucasian, Straight, copy editor, Over
4 Years of College, Middle class, Mesg ID 1032002103332
BACK TO TOP
My husband and I went to visit a good friend who is gay. He was friendly,
but the other gay men in the house seemed hostile toward me (I do not think
homosexuality is wrong). I thought I was imagining things until I read in
an article that there are two types of gay men: those who love women (though
not physically) and those who dislike them. Is this true?
Martha, Enid, OK, United States, 40's, Female, Catholic, White/Caucasian,
Straight, Over 4 Years of College, Middle class, Mesg ID 926200293457
I'm a gay man, 46 years old. Never in my life have I encountered a gay
man who did not like women. It just has never happened to me. In fact, many
gay men identify better with women than men - but I would not generalize
and say that applies to all gay men. So Martha (beautiful name by the way),
WE LOVE YOU!
Glen H., Ottawa, Ontario, NA, Canada, 46, Male, Christian, White/Caucasian,
Gay, Government, High School Diploma, Middle class, Mesg ID 103200212641
BACK TO TOP
Why do some men think it's cool to brag about how much they can eat?
I know guys who act like bottomless pits in a restaurant, yet they have no
clue why their wives refuse to cook for them. What's up with this behavior?
Alma J., Kempner, TX, United States, 49, Female, Methodist, White/Caucasian,
Lesbian, government employee, 4 Years of College, Lower middle class, Mesg
BACK TO TOP
I know this question might
sound offensive, but I live in an area of Melbourne, Australia, with a fairly
large Orthodox Jewish population, and I notice that a fair few of their cars
have the word 'Courier' written on the side. They're just regular cars and
passenger vans, and they don't look like couriers in any way. I was wondering,
are they actually couriers for the community, or do they just put that word
on the side of the car for tax purposes, i.e. to claim the running of a commercial
vehicle? I've always wanted to ask this question in a friendly, curious way,
but I just know I'd seem weird or racist or stupid, or a combination of all
A.J.B., Melbourne, NA, Australia,
<email@example.com>, 37, Male, Atheist, White/Caucasian, Tech Support,
Middle class, Mesg ID 8212002120818
I think you have to ask yourself
some questions. If it was a Christian community, would you question their
motives for the courier sign? Or even notice what you percieve to be an abundancy
of the sign? Would you intially assume that the Christian community was using
the signs to avoid taxes and not because they really were couriers? Would
you assume that all the drivers of these cars were Christians and not people
of a different religion who live in the community as well? Maybe so, maybe
not. But whenever I hear someone attributing behavior in a way that reflects
old religious stereotypes (i.e. that Jews are cheap), I have to wonder. Religion
has nothing to do with it. There are some generous Jews, some cheap ones,
and some in between. Just like there are some generous Christians, some cheap
ones and some in between. There is nothing in Jewish doctrine that promotes
thrift, though there is much that praises generosity. Same goes with Christianity.
My guess is that they are using the signs because they really are couriers.
Until you have any proof to the contrary (other than the stereotypes), I can't
see how you can conclude differently. Most of all, I encourage you to ask
them. Word the question so it doesn't sound accusatory. Ask why there are
so many cars with courier signs in 'OUR' (including yourself as part) community
and not 'YOUR' community (separating yourself from them). I hope this helps.
You seem truly interested in understanding between religions. My hat goes
off to you.
Matt, Boston, MA, United States,
21, Male, Jewish, 4 Years of College, Mesg ID 924200233021
If what you're seeing isn't
just coincidence (i.e. there's a lot of courier cars, and a lot of Jews,
and it just so happens that some of them are together) then it is something
to do with only that particular community in Melbourne.
T., L.os Angeles, CA, United
States, 37, Jewish, Over 4 Years of College, Mesg ID 1032002103213
BACK TO TOP
It's apparent that many
people in society are insensitive to the needs of people who are physically
challenged. The Federal Government created laws to correct this issue. So
why is it that the laws are not implemented?
R. Fristrom, Fairview, TN,
United States, 46, Male, White/Caucasian, Straight, High School Diploma,
Middle class, Mesg ID 514200271509
As with other laws, sometimes
people will not follow them unless forced to do so. As a disability rights
activist and someone with a disability, I have seen at times that the Americans
with Disabilities Act is not followed until a person makes it an issue. Example:
You need a place to stay, and for whatever reason the motel does not provide
access for someone with a disability, and they cannot enter or exit safely.
So you explain the law to the ower, and they still do not fix the problem
- until you talk about getting the legal system involved. Things are improving
because buildings are being made with the ADA in mind.
D. Walter, Sullivan, ME, United
States, 47, Male, Christian, White/Caucasian, Straight, Social Worker, Over
4 Years of College, Lower middle class, Mesg ID 102200255717
BACK TO TOP
Why do many all-night Rave attendees suck on pacifiers?
Demi, Elk Grove, CA, United States, 42, Female, 4 Years of College,
Middle class, Mesg ID 9272002103915
BACK TO TOP
I work at a Mexican restaurant where employees sing if there is a birthday,
and if we don't know the name of the person we're singing the 'Happy Birthday
song' to, we use the name Pancho. A couple of white people, however, have
taken offense to this. Since Pancho just means something like Frank (help
me out if I'm wrong) why were they upset? Or could they have been racists
who used the term as an expletive?
J.C., San Antonio, TX, United States, 21, Male, Hispanic/Latino (may
be any race), Upper middle class, Mesg ID 9272002104259
I'm surprised you haven't heard of these names being used as epithets before.
Maybe epithets is a bit of a strong way of saying it, but white racists routinely
use these names as generic indicators for Mexicans. Remember Pat Buchanan
baiting Latinos with his speeches saying 'Jose, we're not letting you in
[the United States] anymore!' Chances are, these whites had heard the names
used that way by fellow whites who were racists, and assumed you were using
them the same way. I don't think they were racists themselves, though, or
they wouldn't have objected. If they were racists, they would have cheered
A.C.C., Phoenix, AZ, United States, Male, Mexican and American Indian,
Mesg ID 101200251512
BACK TO TOP
Why do Jehovah's Witnesses churches have no windows? I have lived in
five different states, and none of the churches I have seen have them.
Jimmy, Edinburg, TX, United States, 32, Male, Catholic, Student, 2
Years of College, Mesg ID 917200282217
It's funny you ask, because a
friend of mine asked me that once. I didn't know what she was talking about
because the Kingdom Hall (church) I attend has windows. However, depending
on the area, it may be safer to do without windows. I grew up in Chicago,
and in the dangerous neighborhoods, the halls were either windowless or barred.
So it's not all kingdom halls. Probably just a coincidence that the ones you've
passed haven't had them.
Lina, Bradenton, FL, United
States, <firstname.lastname@example.org>, 20, Female, Jehovahs Witness, White/Caucasian,
Straight, Student, 2 Years of College, Mesg ID 923200233053
I was raised a Jehovah's Witness,
and while there's probably no official reason for the lack of windows, my
best guess is that it saves time and money. Witnesses rely on voluntary donations
to raise money to build Kingdom Halls, so the building designs are kept fairly
simple. Also, many of the Kingdom Halls that have been built in the last
20 years or so have been constructed in just a few days, so there isn't time
to put in a lot of extras.
Johnna, Montgomery, AL, United
States, 27, Female, Black/African American, Librarian, Mesg ID 925200210257
Most of my family are Jehovah's
Witnesses, and that is actually a pretty common question. I think the biggest
reason is to avoid vandalism. Rocks through the window can be a pretty expensive
replacement, and Jehovah's Witnesses are an enitirely volunteer-based religion.
They do accept donations, but don't ask for them, so it'd have to come out
of the elders' (head ministers of the congregation's) income, which they
put food on the table with. I think it's just more from problems they've
had in the past, and working to try to avoid them. If you've ever been to
one of their places of worship, though, you'll notice that there usually
are two windows right next to the door, but not always.
Jim, Grafton, WV, United States,
<Synapticfire@hotmail.com>, 18, Male, White/Caucasian, Sales, High
School Diploma, Middle class, Mesg ID 926200283639
BACK TO TOP
Why do you never see black pedophiles in the news?
Igor M., London, NA, United Kingdom, 18, Male, Christian, black Portuguese,
Straight, student, Mesg ID 918200263847
Read a New York City newspaper.
Matthew, New York, NY, United
States, 43, Male, White/Caucasian, Mesg ID 919200265521
BACK TO TOP
Do Muslims smoke cigarettes?
Abby, State College, PA, United States, Mesg ID 916200213844
The answer is yes, many Muslims
smoke cigarettes, cigars, pipes and waterpipes. The religious opinion on
tobacco is hazy at best; although most scholars can give very good reasons
for considering smoking a sin, others can prove it is a hated act but not
sinful. Because there is no clear reference in the Koran or tradition on
smoking (as there is, for example, on alcohol) the matter is highly debatable.
Karim, Cairo, NA, Egypt, 22,
Male, Muslim, Arab, Straight, University T.A., Over 4 Years of College, Middle
class, Mesg ID 919200283427
Some Muslims do smoke cigarettes,
although the religion says you should not. In fact, that's how I got started
smoking during college. I hung around Middle Eastern students who would sit
outside the cafeteria talking politics and smoking cigarettes. Most of the
students were Muslims (Sunni and Shiite), some were Christian, Druze, etc.
After college, I lived with a host family in Jordan. When visiting, often,
the host/hostess would offer a basket filled with different brands of cigarettes.
Culturally, it is frowned upon for women to smoke, but every now and then,
once my host dad left for the mosque (he would usually be gone most of the
day), my host mom would throw money down to one of the kids in the street
to buy us cigarettes and the women would sit and talk and smoke (we would
then have to get rid of the evidence before my host dad came home). None
of this has anything to do with religion, though. I just think smoking is
very popular in the Middle East, particularly for men.
Michelle, Las Vegas, NV, United
States, 36, Female, White/Caucasian, Analyst, Over 4 Years of College, Middle
class, Mesg ID 920200231042
I am an American living in
Turkey, and although I don't know the habits of Muslims in other countries,
I can tell you that Turks do smoke cigarettes. Almost all the men do, and
many city women; it's a sociable thing, and Turks are extremely sociable.
Turkey is also one of the top tobacco-producing countries in the world. As
for adherence to the rules of Islam, Turkey is a country I have heard described
as 'Muslim Lite.' Most Turks (though mostly men) don't shun alcohol, either
- especially a strong aniseed drink called raki, except in a few cities known
to be especially religious.
Patricia, Antalya, NA, Turkey,
29, Female, Agnostic, White/Caucasian, travel, 4 Years of College, Middle
class, Mesg ID 921200243627
I'm really not an expert on
Islam, but as far as I know, smoking is forbidden during the month of Ramadan.
As for the rest of the year, I don't know exactly. I just came back from
Tunisia. There we met two young Tunisians, and I tell you, I've never seen
anybody smoke so much. Asking them whether smoking was allowed in Islam,
they each had different opinions. But they also told us they didn't really
follow Islamic law (praying five times a day, not drinking alcohol, etc.)
yet they considered themselves Muslims. So I guess it very much depends on
what 'kind' of Muslim you are. As with Christians, there are some more liberal
and some very strict followers. But it might even be that smoking is not
forbidden, not even for the most devout Muslims.
Lisa, Zurich, NA, Switzerland,
19, Female, student, Mesg ID 923200223838
I used to live in Geneva, Switzerland,
which has a large population of Muslims. While some go to bars, they don't
drink. They are allowed to smoke, and I saw a lot of them doing that. I don't
believe there is any restriction to smoking in Islam.
John, Boston, MA, United States,
Male, High School Diploma, Mesg ID 924200262051
BACK TO TOP
I'm an Italian American who grew up in New York City. My whole life
I've heard people use the derogatory term 'guinea' when speaking about Italians.
What is the origin of this word?
Ariane M., Ft. Myers, FL, United States, <TropicalToots@aol.com>,
31, Female, Catholic, White/Caucasian, Straight, Estetician, 2 Years of College,
Middle class, Mesg ID 911200265033
When Italians first immigrated
to the New World, they were considered 'black.' Most of the early immigrants
were Southern Italians primarily from Sicily and Naples, and most had dark
complexions. They started using the name Guinea to refer to Italians because
of their dark complexions (Guinea was an African Colony). At least that's
the story I heard.
C. Clear, New York, NY, United
States, Mesg ID 9232002112425
BACK TO TOP
Copyright and disclaimer