Dare to Ask: How do blind people know when to cross a
By Phillip Milano
I've seen blind people waiting at intersections to cross the street, but how
do they know when to cross?
Jennifer, Maryville, Tenn.
When someone goes blind (or is born blind), the other senses attempt to
compensate for the lack of information that the eyes supply. For example, a
blind person can "feel" a wall before they walk into it. ... A blind person's
sense of hearing is more sensitive than the sighted. They listen for cars coming
from the directions of the street they're trying to cross. Some intersections
have bells that ring when it's safe to cross. Others have seeing-eye dogs that
know when to cross.
S.S.R., 49, female, Penn.
They listen to the traffic. When there's none coming from the dangerous
directions, cross. A sighted person can see a blind person at the crosswalk and
ask, "Can I help you?" The blind person could say, "Yes, may I take your arm and
you can lead me across." When assisting a blind person, do not grab their elbow
and push them forward. Rather, offer your arm, and let them hold onto it, and
walk slightly ahead of them, with you leading.
A lot of cities now have crossing lights with audible cues, and even where
these don't exist, there are environmental cues, like a lot of cars stopping, or
other people beginning to walk.
A., 40, Kansas City, Mo.
Sometimes NPR commentator Beth Finke of Chicago, who is blind, is minding her
own business, just standing at a crosswalk even though she's got a green light.
Folks going by think she's got a loser for a seeing-eye dog.
Ah, but Finke's got a vision.
"I like to wait until I hear the traffic rushing back and forth in front of
me stop, and then the traffic that is parallel to me start," said Finke, author
of a children's book about seeing-eye dogs called "Hanni and Beth: Safe & Sound"
as well as the memoir "Long Time, No See." "That way I know it's a fresh green
light, and I have a long time to cross."
Far from being a loser, her dog even practices the Zen-like "intelligent
disobedience" - for example, if it sees traffic coming or a huge pothole, it
won't budge even if Finke orders it to do so.
Close calls? Once a cabbie pulled in front of Finke but her dog stopped on a
dime � Finke petted the "bejesus" out of her after that one � and once an SUV
took a left and nearly squashed them both. Her dog pushed her out of the way,
and neither was seriously hurt.
"The guy said, 'Sorry, I didn't see the dog.' I thought, what am I, chopped
You can help, too: Say "hello" to let her know you're there if she needs
That's better than saying you wish you could take your dog everywhere ("If I
were brave enough [I'd say], 'Well, you could gouge your eyes out.' ") and much
better than petting or distracting her dog when its harness is on.
What about her other senses?
"[People] think blind people hear better or have an enhanced sense of touch.
I often wonder, is there an assumption people who are deaf can 'see' better?"
ADD OR READ MORE COMMENTS
This is your column. You can help it grow! If you like "Dare to Ask,"
please call or e-mail your favorite newspaper or web site and urge them to start
running it. It's syndicated by
Phillip Milano, author of I Can't Believe You Asked That! (Perigee),
moderates cross-cultural dialogue at Y? The National Forum on People's
Differences. Visit www.yforum.com to submit questions and answers. Send general
column comments to firstname.lastname@example.org. You can also hear his
podcasts or watch his